Security operations center with analysts watching threat dashboards
EDR and XDR Comparison

CrowdStrike vs SentinelOne vs Defender. Licensing decides the cost.

A buyer side comparison of CrowdStrike Falcon, SentinelOne Singularity, and Microsoft Defender for Endpoint in 2026. How each platform prices per endpoint, where module bundling and the E5 bundle bite, and how to compare on true cost.

Contact Us Vendor Shield
500+Enterprise clients
$2B+Under advisory
Industry Recognized
500+ Enterprise Clients
$2B+ Under Advisory
11 Vendor Practices
100% Buyer Side Independent

CrowdStrike, SentinelOne, and Microsoft Defender for Endpoint are the three EDR and XDR platforms most often shortlisted, and the licensing model behind each, not the detection demo, decides the true cost per endpoint. Module bundling and platform lock in are where the deals diverge.

Key takeaways

  • All three price per endpoint per year, but the module bundle inside that price differs sharply.
  • CrowdStrike sells modules on the Falcon platform. The base bundle excludes capabilities buyers assume are included.
  • SentinelOne tiers Singularity by Core, Control, and Complete, with managed detection priced on top.
  • Defender for Endpoint is bundled into Microsoft E5 and add on SKUs, which changes the comparison entirely.
  • The Microsoft bundle can look free if you already own E5, but the security capability gap is real.
  • Compare on true cost per endpoint per year with the modules you actually need, not on the base SKU.

This pillar is for security and procurement leaders running an EDR or XDR selection or renewal in 2026. Read it with the CrowdStrike Falcon negotiation guide, the Defender Plan 1 versus Plan 2 guide, and Vendor Shield.

How is each endpoint platform priced?

All three price per endpoint per year, but the capability inside the base price is where they split. Read the bundle, not the rate.

How does CrowdStrike Falcon price?

CrowdStrike sells discrete modules on the Falcon platform, from base prevention up to identity protection and threat intelligence. The base bundle is narrower than buyers expect. CrowdStrike lists its bundles on its platform bundles page.

How does SentinelOne Singularity price?

SentinelOne tiers Singularity into Core, Control, and Complete, with managed detection and response priced separately. SentinelOne outlines the tiers on its platform page.

How does Microsoft Defender for Endpoint price?

Defender for Endpoint comes in Plan 1 and Plan 2, and Plan 2 is bundled into Microsoft 365 E5 and the E5 Security add on. Microsoft documents this on its Defender for Endpoint page.

How do the three compare on true cost?

Normalize to true cost per endpoint per year with the modules you actually need. The base SKU is a poor guide because the capability gaps differ.

EDR and XDR licensing model comparison, illustrative

Dimension CrowdStrike SentinelOne Defender
Pricing unitPer endpoint, modulePer endpoint, tierPer user, bundle
Base capabilityPreventionCore EDRPlan 1 or Plan 2
Add on driverModule stackTier and MDRE5 bundle
Best fitSecurity first buyersAutonomous responseMicrosoft E5 estates

Which add on modules change the picture?

  • CrowdStrike: Identity Protection, Threat Intelligence, Discover, and managed Falcon Complete.
  • SentinelOne: the step from Control to Complete, plus Vigilance managed response.
  • Defender: the gap between Plan 1 and Plan 2, and the wider E5 Security suite.

Where the common advice on EDR selection is wrong

The standard advice is to buy Defender because it is already in your E5 license and looks free. We disagree. In roughly 1 in 3 Microsoft estates we benchmarked, the capability gap forced add ons or a second tool that erased the saving.

The buyer side move is to map the capabilities you actually require, then price all three at that capability level. Free in the bundle is not free if it does not cover the requirement.

Security operations analyst monitoring threat dashboards on multiple screens
The base EDR SKU rarely matches the capability buyers assume. The module stack above it is where the real cost and the real coverage live.
40-90%
Add ons over base SKU
1/3
Deals swung by E5 bundle
15-30%
Multi year prepay discount

Source: Redress Compliance advisory engagement file, 2024 to 2025.

The EDR you should buy is the one that meets your real capability requirement at the lowest cost per endpoint, not the one that ships free inside a license you already hold.

What to do next

  1. Write the capability requirement before you look at any vendor SKU.
  2. Price all three at that capability level, including the modules you need.
  3. Test whether Defender in E5 truly covers the requirement or forces add ons.
  4. Normalize to true cost per endpoint per year across the full term.
  5. Quantify the multi year prepay discount against annual flexibility.
  6. Benchmark each price against comparable enterprises.
  7. Run the negotiation with an independent advisor and a credible alternative in play.

Frequently asked questions

Which is best, CrowdStrike, SentinelOne, or Defender?

There is no single best platform for every estate. The right choice depends on your capability requirement, your existing Microsoft licensing, and your appetite for managed response. Compare on true cost per endpoint at the capability level you actually need.

How does CrowdStrike Falcon pricing work?

CrowdStrike sells modules on the Falcon platform, from base prevention up to identity protection, threat intelligence, and managed Falcon Complete. The base bundle is narrower than many buyers expect, so the module stack drives most of the real per endpoint cost.

How is SentinelOne Singularity priced?

SentinelOne tiers Singularity into Core, Control, and Complete, with managed detection and response priced separately. Moving from Control to Complete and adding Vigilance managed response are the main cost drivers above the base tier.

Is Microsoft Defender for Endpoint free with E5?

Defender for Endpoint Plan 2 is included in Microsoft 365 E5 and the E5 Security add on, so it can appear free if you already own E5. The real question is whether its capability covers your requirement without forcing additional tools or modules.

What is the difference between Defender Plan 1 and Plan 2?

Plan 1 provides core endpoint protection and response, while Plan 2 adds advanced hunting, automated investigation, and threat and vulnerability management. Plan 2 is the version bundled into E5, and the gap between the two is a frequent source of confusion in cost comparisons.

How much do EDR add on modules cost?

Add on modules commonly increase the per endpoint price by 40 to 90 percent over the base SKU, depending on the platform and the capabilities selected. This is why the base SKU price is a poor guide to the real cost of a deployment.

Do multi year contracts reduce EDR pricing?

Yes. Multi year prepay commitments commonly secure 15 to 30 percent off annual billing, but they reduce flexibility if your endpoint count or requirements change. Weigh the discount against the lock in before committing to a long term.

How do I negotiate an EDR renewal?

Keep a credible alternative platform in the evaluation, benchmark your per endpoint price, and price the exact module set you use rather than the vendor bundle. An independent advisor at the table helps secure discounts and caps the sales motion resists.

Endpoint Security Negotiation Guide

The full endpoint security negotiation guide framework from the Vendor Shield.

EDR and XDR pricing benchmarks, module bundling traps, true cost per endpoint, and the buyer side moves across CrowdStrike, SentinelOne, and Microsoft Defender.

Used across more than five hundred enterprise engagements. Independent. Buyer side. Built for procurement leaders running the next renewal cycle.

No spam. We will only email you about this download. Privacy.
Run the software spend health check on your security stack in under five minutes.
Open the Tool →
3
Platforms compared
40-90%
Add ons over base
1/3
Swung by E5 bundle
15-30%
Multi year discount
100%
Buyer Side

The standard advice is to buy Defender because it is already in your E5 and looks free. We disagree. In a third of Microsoft estates we benchmarked, the capability gap forced add ons that erased the saving. The buyer side move is to price all three at the capability you actually need.

Morten Andersen
Co Founder. Ex IBM, ex Oracle.
Deep Library

More on this topic.

Vendor Shield →
Cybersecurity padlock visualization
Security
CrowdStrike Falcon Negotiation Guide
Module pricing, bundle traps, and the buyer side levers on a Falcon renewal.
11 min read
Network nodes visualization
Microsoft
Defender for Endpoint P1 vs P2
What separates Plan 1 from Plan 2 and what the E5 bundle really includes.
9 min read
Server racks in a data center aisle
Security
Carbon Black XDR Licensing
How Broadcom prices Carbon Black XDR and where the enterprise traps sit.
10 min read
Editorial boardroom interior

The advisor your vendors do not want.

500+ enterprise clients. 11 vendor practices. Industry recognized. One conversation can change what you pay for the next three years.

Security licensing brief. Once a week.

One short note on endpoint security pricing moves, EDR and XDR bundling traps, true cost per endpoint, and the buyer side levers we run in client engagements. No noise.