10 Things SAP System Owners Should Know About SAP ERP Private Cloud
SAP ERP Private Cloud (often delivered through offerings like RISE with SAP) is a single-tenant cloud ERP model that combines the flexibility of on-premise SAP with the benefits of cloud infrastructure.
For IT executives, this means navigating a new subscription licensing model, understanding cost drivers and contract terms, and preparing for responsibility shifts.
Below are ten key insights – each with an explanation and a recommendation – to help SAP system owners make informed decisions about SAP ERP Private Cloud.
1. New Subscription Licensing (FUE Model)
What it is:
Traditional SAP ERP licensing (perpetual named-user licenses) is replaced by a subscription based on Full User Equivalents (FUE) – a pooled capacity measure.
Instead of buying individual licenses, you subscribe to several FUEs, which represent your total user capacity. Different user types (e.g., casual self-service users versus power users) are counted as fractional FUEs. This model provides flexibility to allocate users as needed within the purchased capacity.
Why it matters:
It shifts SAP to an OpEx model – you pay recurring fees for what you use, and you can reassign user roles without buying new licenses (as long as you stay within your FUE allotment). However, SAP often requires a minimum FUE commitment (e.g., dozens of FUEs), which could be a factor for smaller deployments.
Recommendation: Analyze your current user base and roles to estimate FUE needs before signing. Convert your named users to FUE to avoid over- or under-subscribing. Ensure you understand how each user type consumes FUE so you can right-size the subscription.
10 Things IT Sourcing Should Know About SAP ERP Private Cloud
2. Understand the Cost Premium and TCO
What it is:
SAP ERP Private Cloud typically costs 15–30% more per user than SAP’s public cloud (SaaS) version. You are paying a premium for a dedicated environment and added flexibility.
SAP uses tiered pricing – the more users (FUEs) you commit, the lower the per-user cost. Longer contract terms can also lower annual rates. For example, 1,000 users might cost around $2M/year in a private cloud vs. $1.8M in public cloud, reflecting the premium for isolation and control.
Why it matters: While initial subscription quotes may seem attractive compared to on-premises costs (which include hardware and maintenance), the total cost of ownership (TCO) over 5-7 years can be higher in the cloud.
The subscription includes infrastructure and certain services, but you must evaluate whether the cloud benefits (e.g., faster innovation, scalability, reduced hardware overhead) justify the premium in the long run.
Recommendation:
Model your 5-year TCO for private cloud vs. staying on-prem. Include subscription fees plus migration, integration, and any new cloud services. Leverage SAP’s volume discounts and consider conversion credits for existing licenses to offset costs. Always negotiate – large enterprises can often secure better per-user pricing or incentives.
3. Infrastructure Is Managed by SAP (with SLAs)
What it is:
In SAP’s private cloud model, your ERP system is hosted by SAP (often on a hyperscaler like AWS, Azure, or GCP) in a single-tenant environment dedicated to your company.
The subscription covers the SAP software licenses and the underlying infrastructure, including hardware, databases, and data center operations.
SAP provides a Service Level Agreement (SLA) for uptime (typically ~99.7% or higher) and handles routine backups, patching, and technical upgrades to the system.
Why it matters: For IT leaders, this outsources the infrastructure burden – no more buying servers or worrying about hardware refresh cycles.
It can enhance reliability and security posture through enterprise-grade data centers and built-in disaster recovery capabilities.
However, you relinquish some control over the environment to SAP, and you must align with their maintenance schedules and cloud operating procedures.
Recommendation:
Take advantage of SAP’s managed infrastructure to repurpose your internal IT resources towards higher-value activities.
Verify the SLA and support processes in the contract (e.g., how outages are handled). Als,o ensure the chosen data center regions meet your compliance needs, and plan connectivity so your other systems can securely integrate with the SAP cloud environment.
4. You’re Still Responsible for Implementation and Support
What it is:
SAP ERP Private Cloud is not a turnkey SaaS solution – while SAP manages the infrastructure and standard maintenance, you (or your implementation partner) are responsible for setting up the system, customizing it, and providing ongoing application support.
The subscription does not include initial implementation projects, data migration, or Application Management Services (AMS) for end-users. Those remain your responsibility, much like in on-prem deployments.
Why it matters:
Moving to a private cloud doesn’t eliminate the need for a skilled SAP team or a System Integrator (SI). You’ll need to plan and budget for the one-time migration project and possibly re-engineering processes for S/4HANA if coming from ECC.
Post go-live, user support, configurations, and enhancements will either need in-house SAP talent or an AMS partner contract.
Essentially, SAP’s role is to keep the technical platform running, but business continuity and system optimization are still on you.
Recommendation:
Budget for the “hidden” costs beyond the subscription fee. This includes:*
- Implementation and data migration: e.g., hiring a consulting partner to deploy S/4HANA and move your data.
- Integration and add-ons: connecting SAP to other systems (which may require middleware or additional SAP Cloud services not included in the base subscription).
- Ongoing support: either internal IT staff or an external AMS provider to handle user support, security administration, minor enhancements, and monitoring.
Ensure these plans are in place so your cloud migration delivers value without disrupting operations.
5. High Flexibility for Customization
What it is:
Unlike multi-tenant SaaS ERP, where you are constrained to standardized processes, SAP’s Private Cloud lets you customize the system almost as freely as traditional on-premise SAP.
You can retain specific industry add-ons, custom ABAP code, and third-party extensions. SAP S/4HANA Private Cloud (private edition) essentially provides a dedicated instance of S/4HANA, allowing you to decide. When to apply updates (within SAP’s agreed upgrade windows), and you can adapt the software to unique business needs.
Why it matters:
For enterprises with complex or differentiated processes, this model provides the best of both worlds – cloud benefits with on-premise-level flexibility. You won’t be forced into a one-size-fits-all template.
However, greater customization can lead to increased complexity.
Highly customized systems may require more testing during upgrades and can reduce agility if not managed well. There’s also a tendency to carry over old customizations that might be better replaced with standard solutions.
Recommendation:
Use the move to SAP Private Cloud as an opportunity to review and rationalize customizations. Keep the ones that truly deliver competitive advantage and eliminate obsolete or redundant mods.
Ensure your team follows SAP’s recommended “clean core” approach (using SAP BTP for extensions where possible) to make future upgrades smoother. In short, enjoy the flexibility but govern it with clear architecture principles.
6. Extras Are Included – But Watch the Limits
What it is:
SAP often bundles valuable extras with a private cloud subscription.
Common inclusions are SAP BTP (Business Technology Platform) credits (for building extensions and integrations), a starter pack of SAP Ariba Network transactions (e.g., several thousand supplier documents), and tools such as SAP Signavio process analysis reports to aid in business transformation.
Standard disaster recovery and high-availability provisions are also included in the service. These inclusions are designed to jump-start your cloud journey.
Why it matters:
These bundled items can provide immediate value – for example, utilizing the included BTP credits to build a custom app that is needed, or leveraging the provided process mining report to identify process improvements during the migration.
However, the key is that these are typically limited in terms of quotas. If you consume beyond the included amount (for example, if you require more BTP resources or exchange a significantly higher volume of documents on the Ariba Network), you will incur additional fees.
Recommendation: Inventory the “freebies” in your SAP Private Cloud contract and assess your likely usage. Plan and budget for going beyond those limits before you reach your limit. For instance, if you know your procurement volume will exceed the included Ariba documents or that you’ll heavily use BTP for extensions, negotiate upfront for better rates or higher limits. Don’t let an initial free allotment lull you into costly overages later.
7. Multi-Year Contracts – Plan User Counts and Growth Carefully
What it is:
An SAP Private Cloud agreement typically entails a 3 to 5-year locked-in contract. You commit to a certain number of FUEs (and services) for the duration. During this term, you cannot generally reduce your subscription count or drop services until the renewal.
You can increase the number of users (by purchasing additional FUEs), but you’re committing to pay for at least your contracted minimum each year, regardless of whether you use them or not.
Any overuse (i.e., exceeding your FUEs) typically requires a “true-up” payment at renewal or an immediate contract adjustment.
Why it matters:
This is essentially a cloud with a fixed commitment, not pay-as-you-go scaling down. If your company downsizes or consolidates, you may be required to continue paying for unused capacity until the term ends.
Conversely, if you grow, you need to budget for adding users (often at the original per-FUE rate if negotiated, or potentially higher if not locked in). The inability to shrink the subscription mid-term is a key planning concern.
Additionally, these contracts often have renewal clauses – after the term, prices can increase (sometimes significantly) if not negotiated.
Recommendation: Size your contract prudently. Commit to what you truly need and consider phasing the ramp-up of users if possible.
Negotiate flexibility such as the right to add FUEs at the same discount rate or to adjust downwards at renewal if business conditions change.
Also, seek to cap any price increases on renewal in your contract. In short, avoid over-committing, and build in any wiggle room you can for the unexpected.
8. Keep an Eye on Indirect Access and Compliance
What it is:
Indirect/digital access refers to scenarios where external systems or automation (like an e-commerce site, middleware, or bots) interact with your SAP system.
In SAP ERP Private Cloud, although licensing is subscription-based, you must still ensure compliance for indirect usage scenarios.
SAP typically includes certain provisions (e.g., a specified number of document transactions for external access), but heavy integrations may require additional licensing (often via an add-on for digital access, if not covered in your RISE package). Audit rights for SAP also still apply – SAP can audit your usage against contractual terms.
Why it matters:
Many enterprises integrate SAP with numerous other systems. Unforeseen licensing liability can arise if, for example, a customer portal indirectly triggers lots of SAP transactions that weren’t accounted for.
Additionally, using SAP’s private cloud doesn’t eliminate the need for proper user management and license compliance – you must ensure you’re not exceeding your FUE count or violating usage terms. Non-compliance could lead to hefty fees.
Recommendation:
Map out all systems and processes that interface with SAP. Discuss with SAP how digital access is handled in the contract – ideally get an allotment of external transactions or an enterprise indirect use license.
Implement monitoring for external API calls or document creations in SAP. On the user side, regularly review your user list and deactivate unused accounts to stay within your FUE subscription. Proactive compliance management will prevent unpleasant surprises.
9. Plan Your Exit Strategy and Data Ownership
What it is:
With SAP managing your ERP in their cloud, you need to consider vendor lock-in and how to exit if needed. Extracting your data and potentially migrating to another solution (or reverting to on-premises) can be complex.
While your data is your property, the process and cost of retrieving it in a usable form at contract end should be clearly understood.
Additionally, if you decide not to renew the private cloud subscription, there may be implications – for example, you may need to revert to on-premises licensing (if possible) or migrate to a different platform quickly.
Why it matters:
Enterprises must avoid being trapped in a scenario where they have no leverage at renewal time or face disruption if they switch to a new provider. Knowing the exit terms (such as how long SAP will retain your data, whether they will assist in migrating it out, and whether there are fees for data extraction, etc.) is critical.
Additionally, consider contract clauses regarding termination: can you extend the contract in the short term if your next platform isn’t ready? These factors influence your negotiating power and continuity planning.
Recommendation:
Negotiate clear exit provisions in the contract. Ensure you have the right to access and export your full data, and define any support SAP must provide to facilitate a smooth transition out.
Try to avoid automatic renewals – maintain a point to renegotiate terms or consider alternatives at least every few years. As a best practice, maintain a data backup or copy (if feasible) and documentation of configurations to ease any future migration. Even if you plan to stay with SAP long-term, having an exit plan gives you flexibility and leverage.
10. Treat It as a Transformation Opportunity, Not Just Hosting
What it is:
Moving to SAP ERP Private Cloud is often part of a broader program like RISE with SAP, which aims to enable business transformation.
Beyond the technical migration, SAP provides tools (e.g., business process intelligence via Signavio, and BTP for innovation) to help re-engineer and modernize your processes during the move. This is an opportunity to transition from legacy ERP systems (such as SAP ECC) to SAP S/4HANA, leveraging modern best practices on a cloud platform.
Why it matters:
Simply lifting and shifting your old ERP to a new environment misses the full value. IT executives should align private cloud migration with strategic goals, including process simplification, data cleanup, and the adoption of intelligent technologies.
Additionally, consider change management – cloud adoption can change how teams work (for instance, faster update cycles, new user interfaces like Fiori, etc.). Organizations that approach the project as a business transformation (not just an IT project) tend to see better ROI from SAP Private Cloud.
Recommendation:
Partner with business leaders to reimagine processes and user experiences during the migration. Leverage the included tools and services; for example, utilize SAP Signavio Insights to identify process inefficiencies and address them.
Develop a roadmap for continuous improvement post-migration – the cloud platform makes it easier to adopt innovations (like AI/ML services or analytics on SAP Data). In short, seize the move as a catalyst for modernization, not merely a change in infrastructure.
Recommendations (Practical Tips for Success)
- Audit and Right-Size Before Signing: Thoroughly review your current SAP users and usage. Eliminate or reassign idle licenses so you subscribe only to the capacity you need. A lean starting point saves cost.
- Negotiate for Flexibility and Discounts: Use your enterprise bargaining power. Push for volume discounts and lock in favorable rates for adding users. Where possible, include clauses to adjust for business changes (e.g. M&A or divestitures) and to cap price increases at renewal.
- Leverage SAP Incentives: Inquire about conversion credits for your existing licenses or any promotional deals. SAP often offers incentives for switching to the cloud (like crediting past maintenance fees or bundling additional software). Don’t leave these on the table – they can significantly reduce cost.
- Plan Beyond the Subscription: Identify any additional capacity or services you’ll likely need and budget for them from the start. For example, if you anticipate heavy use of SAP BTP or require additional SAP cloud modules (such as SuccessFactors), negotiate these into your contract or establish a cost plan. Surprises mid-term can be expensive, so plan holistically.
- Establish Governance and Monitor Usage: Treat your SAP subscription like a living contract. Set up governance to regularly track user counts, feature usage, and performance against SLAs. This helps catch when you’re nearing licensed limits or if you have excess capacity to reallocate. Proactive monitoring avoids compliance issues and waste.
- Engage Expert Help if Needed: If navigating SAP contracts and licensing is outside your team’s comfort zone, consider bringing in an SAP licensing advisor or consulting firm. Their expertise in benchmarks and negotiation tactics can pay for itself in cost savings or risk avoidance on a large enterprise deal.
Checklist: 5 Actions to Take
- Assess Current State: Document your existing SAP landscape – user counts by role, customizations, integrations, and total cost of ownership today. This baseline will guide your private cloud requirements and highlight areas to streamline before migration.
- Project Future Needs: Work with business units to forecast growth or changes over the next 3-5 years. Plan for new users, new modules, or acquisitions so your contract can accommodate them. Also, identify legacy processes that could be optimized in the new system.
- Solicit Proposals and Benchmarks: Engage SAP (and possibly alternative providers) for a private cloud proposal. In parallel, consult independent sources or peer benchmarks on pricing and terms. Understand market rates and best practices – this will strengthen your negotiating position.
- Negotiate and finalize the contract, focusing on the critical terms: FUE volume, price per FUE, contract length, included services, and exit clauses. Ensure any promises (like license credits or specific SLAs) are written into the agreement. Don’t rush this phase; involve your procurement and legal teams to cover compliance, data protection, and future flexibility.
- Prepare for Implementation & Beyond: Line up the resources for a successful migration. Select an implementation partner (or internal project team) and define a timeline that accounts for data migration, testing, and user training. Simultaneously, set up a post-go-live support model and a cloud governance board to oversee ongoing operations and the relationship with SAP. Being prepared on these fronts will smooth the transition and help realize benefits more quickly.
FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)
Q1: How is SAP ERP Private Cloud different from SAP’s public cloud or on-premises?
A: SAP ERP Private Cloud (S/4HANA Cloud, private edition) is a single-tenant deployment dedicated to one customer, allowing extensive customization and control – much like an on-prem system, but hosted by SAP. In contrast, the public cloud (S/4HANA Cloud, public edition) is a multi-tenant SaaS solution, offering a standardized solution with quarterly updates and limited flexibility. Both are subscription-based. The private option costs more per user but lets you decide on the timing of upgrades and preserve unique processes. Compared to on-premises, private cloud shifts infrastructure responsibility to SAP and utilizes subscription licensing; however, functionally, it’s the same software running on HANA, with the added benefit of cloud services and faster provisioning of hardware resources.
Q2: Will SAP handle all updates and maintenance for us in the Private Cloud?
A: SAP will take care of technical upgrades, patches, and system upkeep at the infrastructure and application platform level (including applying support packs and HANA database updates). However, you still have control over when major version upgrades occur – for example, you coordinate with SAP to schedule your S/4HANA upgrades within a given window, allowing you time to test. It’s not “auto-update” like a pure SaaS; you get some flexibility. Routine maintenance, such as backups and OS/DB security patching, is handled by SAP. You are still responsible for testing your business processes after updates, adjusting custom code as needed, and managing any new features or configurations that accompany the updates.
Q3: What happens to our existing SAP licenses if we move to SAP Private Cloud?
A: Typically, when you transition to the RISE with SAP Private Cloud subscription, your existing on-premise licenses are put on hold or retired for the duration of the subscription. You will stop paying annual maintenance on those licenses. In many cases, SAP offers to convert some of your license investment into credits toward the subscription (this is negotiated on a case-by-case basis). Keep in mind that once you’re in the subscription model, you generally cannot use the old perpetual licenses unless you exit the subscription. It’s essential to clarify with SAP whether there’s a possibility to revert to on-premises or how long you can keep those old licenses active (often, they allow a short overlap period for transition). The expectation, however, is that you will be fully transitioning to the new licensing model.
Q4: Can we adjust our user count or subscription down the line if our needs change?
A: You can increase your subscribed FUEs (for example, if you hire more people or expand operations, you can add users by purchasing additional FUEs), but you generally cannot decrease the committed number of FUEs until the end of the contract term. This means if you over-estimate and your user count drops, you’ll still pay for the higher number for the remainder of the term. At renewal time, you could attempt to adjust the numbers. It’s crucial to get the initial sizing right. Some companies negotiate a degree of flexibility (like the option to reduce at renewal or a one-time mid-term adjustment for extraordinary events). Still, those are exceptions rather than the norm.
Q5: Besides the subscription fee, what other costs or considerations should we plan for?
A: In addition to the subscription fee itself, plan for:
- Implementation and Migration Costs: The project to migrate to S/4HANA Private Cloud (system setup, data migration, testing, and retraining users) can be significant and is typically a one-time investment paid to implementation partners or internal project efforts.
- Integration and Additional Software: If you have other systems (e.g., CRM, data warehouse), budget for integration work and any necessary middleware or cloud connectors. Additionally, if you plan to use other SAP cloud products (such as SuccessFactors for HR and Ariba for procurement), these are licensed separately from the core ERP private cloud.
- Ongoing Support and Enhancements: You may need to either bolster your internal IT support team or contract an AMS provider for ongoing support and maintenance. Users will need a help desk, minor enhancements will be needed over time, and you’ll want to continuously optimize your processes. These resources incur ongoing operational costs.
In summary, the SAP ERP Private Cloud subscription provides the platform “as a service,” but you must invest in deploying and running it optimally to fully realize its value.
Read about our SAP Advisory services for Rise.
