10 Things ITAM Professionals Should Know About SAP ERP Private Cloud
SAP ERP Private Cloud is a subscription-based, fully managed ERP offering that changes how enterprises license SAP software. IT asset management (ITAM) professionals must understand the key differences between on-premise SAP and cloud–based SAP,
including subscription costs, contract lock-in, compliance requirements, and flexibility. This advisory note highlights 10 essential things ITAM pros should know, with insights and recommendations to navigate SAP ERP Private Cloud effectively.
1. Subscription Model Shifts SAP Costs to OpEx
In SAP ERP Private Cloud, you don’t buy the software – you subscribe to it.
The big upfront license purchase is replaced by recurring fees that include the software, infrastructure, and support. This shifts ERP spending from a capital expense to an operating expense.
The upside: no huge upfront cost and SAP handles hosting and updates. The downside: you lose perpetual rights – if you stop subscribing, you lose access. Over multiple years, those subscription payments add up, so long-term budgeting is essential.
Recommendation: Plan your budget for the long haul. Treat the subscription like a continuous utility cost, and negotiate multi-year price protections (e.g., caps on annual fee increases) to keep costs predictable.
Top 10 Things CIOs Should Know About SAP ERP Private Cloud
2. All-in-One Bundled Contract – Know What’s Included
SAP ERP Private Cloud (often delivered via RISE with SAP) bundles multiple elements under a single contract. Software licenses, the HANA database, cloud infrastructure, and standard support are all included in a single fee.
This simplifies vendor management, but you need to know exactly what you’re paying for. Some deals include extras like limited SAP Business Technology Platform credits or other cloud services – these come with usage caps, and if you exceed them, you’ll face additional charges.
Also, the all-in-one pricing can obscure the cost breakdown, making it hard to benchmark individual components.
Recommendation: Demand transparency. Ask SAP to clearly outline everything included in the subscription and any applicable limits (e.g., users, storage, transactions).
Remove or scale down bundled services you won’t use to avoid paying for shelfware. By understanding the fine print, you can avoid unexpected charges in your SAP ERP Private Cloud agreement.
3. New Licensing Metrics: Named Users & FUEs
SAP ERP Private Cloud uses Full User Equivalents (FUEs) as its licensing metric.
Instead of buying separate license types, you purchase a pool of FUEs that cover different user roles – heavy users consume more FUEs, light self-service users consume fewer. SAP often requires a minimum FUE commitment to start a private cloud subscription.
The FUE model is flexible because you can allocate your pool across various user types and reassign licenses as roles change.
However, you still must manage named users carefully: every individual needs an appropriate license assignment, and if your usage exceeds your FUE pool, you’ll need to expand the contract.
Recommendation: Track user assignments and FUE consumption closely. Classify each user under the right license type to optimize your FUE pool (e.g., don’t give a full Professional user license to someone who only needs occasional access).
Perform regular audits of user activity and deactivate dormant accounts. This ensures you stay within your subscription limits and catch any need for additional licenses early.
4. Minimum Commitments and Limited Flexibility
When you commit to SAP ERP Private Cloud, you agree to a certain number of users (or FUEs) and a contract term (typically 3–5 years). You’re locked into paying for that minimum usage, whether or not you fully utilize it.
Unlike on-premise licenses, you generally cannot scale down mid-term – if you end up needing fewer users, you still pay for the committed quantity until renewal.
Scaling up is easier: you can add users or extra modules during the term (usually via a contract addendum), but of course, that raises costs. The cloud model offers agility for growth but is less forgiving if you need to shrink.
Recommendation: Start with a realistic user count and scope. Avoid over-committing on day one; it’s better to add users later than pay for unused licenses.
Negotiate for rightsizing at renewal – for example, the ability to adjust user numbers or swap modules when your term is up.
If you expect growth, consider locking in predetermined rates for adding users, so you know the cost of scaling up.
5. Migration and Dual-Use Rights
During the move from SAP ECC on-premise to SAP ERP Private Cloud, you may need to run the old and new systems in parallel for a short time. Without proper terms, this overlap can result in double licensing costs or compliance risk.
SAP may allow a dual-use period – for example, running your legacy system in read-only mode for a few months after S/4HANA go-live – but you must negotiate it and get it in writing.
Otherwise, you may find yourself in a situation where you’re expected to pay for both environments.
Recommendation: Secure a written transition agreement for parallel use. Negotiate a reasonable dual-use window (e.g., 3–6 months) to finalize data migration and user training without incurring duplicate costs.
This ensures you won’t be penalized for keeping your old system running briefly during the cutover to SAP ERP Private Cloud.
6. Indirect Access and Third-Party Integrations
Even in the cloud, SAP’s indirect access rules still apply. If non-SAP systems or external users interact with your SAP data (for example, a customer portal creating orders in SAP), you need to have that covered in your license.
Typically, this means purchasing SAP’s Digital Access licenses (based on document counts) or ensuring each external user has an appropriate SAP user license. Don’t assume moving to the cloud makes interfaces “free” – it doesn’t.
Also, be mindful of any integration services included in your contract (for instance, an SAP Integration Suite allowance or connectors to SAP Ariba); these often have limits, and exceeding them will incur extra fees.
Recommendation: Identify all third-party systems and interfaces that connect to SAP. During negotiation, include the necessary indirect usage in your subscription – for example, negotiate a bundle of Digital Access documents if you expect high volumes of documents from external systems.
Cover this upfront rather than facing an unexpected compliance claim later. In short, whether cloud-based or not, ensure that every way SAP is accessed is properly licensed.
7. Customizations and Upgrade Management
SAP ERP Private Cloud (the private S/4HANA edition) allows you to customize your system almost as much as an on-premise deployment.
You receive your dedicated instance, allowing you to transport custom ABAP code, apply modifications, and utilize third-party add-ons as needed for your business.
This flexibility is a big advantage for enterprises with complex needs. However, remember that SAP manages the environment and will apply regular patches and updates. You must stay on a supported software version.
Major upgrades will still occur (on a schedule agreed with SAP), and you’ll be expected to adopt the new release within a given timeframe. Any custom code will need to be adjusted and tested for each upgrade cycle.
Recommendation: Keep customizations as lean as possible and follow “clean core” principles (avoid altering standard SAP code unnecessarily). This makes it easier to apply SAP’s updates.
Plan for periodic upgrade projects in your cloud roadmap – allocate time and resources every year or two to test and adapt your custom code to the latest version.
By striking a balance between flexibility and discipline, you can enjoy the benefits of customization without falling behind on required updates.
8. Cost Drivers and Total Cost of Ownership
Subscription fees are only one part of the cost story. ITAM professionals should account for all the cost elements of running SAP ERP Private Cloud.
Key cost drivers include:
- Implementation & Migration: One-time project costs for deploying the new system, migrating data, and initial training. These are often significant – sometimes as much as your first year’s subscription fee (or more, depending on project scope).
- Integration & Add-Ons: The expense of integrating SAP with other systems (middleware, APIs) or licensing additional SAP cloud services/modules not included in the base subscription.
- Internal Support: You’ll still need skilled personnel (in-house or a partner) for ongoing tasks such as user administration, configuration, security, and liaison with SAP support. Cloud hosting cuts infrastructure work, but application support remains.
- Growth & Overage: If your usage increases – more users, more transactions, or more data – your costs will also increase. You may reach a threshold that requires a higher subscription tier or additional purchases (for example, purchasing extra storage or more FUEs).
Over the course of 5 years, these factors, combined with subscription fees, determine your true total cost of ownership (TCO). Cloud doesn’t eliminate costs; it redistributes them (and can introduce new ones, such as cloud integration tools or data egress fees).
Recommendation: Model your multi-year TCO for SAP ERP Private Cloud. Include all categories – subscription fees, implementation, integrations, ongoing support, and a buffer for growth. Use this model to budget accurately and to evaluate the cloud deal’s viability. Revisit your cost model annually to adjust for actual usage and avoid budget surprises.
9. Negotiating Contract Pitfalls
When negotiating an SAP ERP Private Cloud contract, be vigilant about common pitfalls and lock-in tactics.
A few things to watch for:
- Steep Renewal Costs: The initial term might come with discounts. Ensure that you cap any price increases at renewal (e.g., no more than 5% or a fixed renewal price) to avoid a cost spike later.
- Rigid Terms: Without negotiation, you may have zero flexibility to reduce users or drop components until the contract ends. Push for the right to adjust down at renewal or swap out unused services.
- Undefined Metrics: Ensure that all metrics and usage definitions are clearly defined and documented. Don’t accept vague wording like “SAP policies apply” without specifics – ambiguity can lead to disputes or extra charges down the road.
- Bundled Shelfware: SAP might bundle in extra cloud products “at no charge” to sweeten the deal (e.g., a pilot of SAP Analytics Cloud or other add-ons). Remember that the cost is likely built in somewhere. If you don’t need the extras, consider negotiating them out to focus your spending on what you will actually use.
Recommendation: Involve your procurement and legal teams early, and consider using an independent SAP licensing advisor. Everything is negotiable. Ensure that pricing, usage limits, renewal terms, and exit options are all explicitly documented in the contract (not just promised verbally). A well-negotiated SAP ERP Private Cloud contract will save money and prevent headaches later.
10. Vendor Lock-In and Exit Strategy
Moving to SAP’s cloud is a strategic commitment that can increase your dependency on the vendor.
In a traditional setup, owning perpetual licenses provided some autonomy – you could switch hosting providers or even stop paying maintenance and continue using the software (albeit without support).
In SAP ERP Private Cloud, you’re fully tied to SAP’s environment and terms. If you become unhappy with SAP’s service or pricing, switching away isn’t easy – there’s no quick fallback to on-premise without a major reimplementation.
And when your term ends, you face a renewal cliff: you must either renew (often at a higher price) or risk losing access to your mission-critical system. ITAM professionals should prepare management for this and mitigate the risks.
Recommendation: Go into the cloud with a clear exit strategy. Negotiate provisions for assistance if you decide to leave (for example, SAP helping with data export, or at least a read-only access period after contract end). Internally, keep backups of your data and documentation of custom configurations so you’re not caught off guard.
Stay informed about the market and alternatives, even if you plan to stick with SAP in the long term.
By planning for the worst-case (exit), you’ll handle the relationship with SAP more confidently and maintain leverage throughout your contract.
Recommendations (Practical Tips)
- Baseline your SAP usage: Before you migrate, audit your current SAP licenses and usage. Know how many users and what modules you use. This baseline prevents overbuying in the cloud and strengthens your case during negotiations.
- Build a multi-year cost plan: Project a five-year total cost of ownership for staying on-premises vs. moving to SAP ERP Private Cloud. Include everything (licenses, maintenance, infrastructure vs. subscription fees, project costs). Use this analysis to set realistic expectations and support your negotiation strategy.
- Negotiate flexibility and incentives: Push SAP for terms that allow future adjustments. For example, secure rights to reduce licenses at renewal or pre-agreed rates for adding users mid-term. Also, explore incentive programs – SAP often offers credits for unused on-prem licenses or discounts for bundling products. Don’t accept the first offer; counter for a more flexible deal.
- Cover indirect use upfront: If you have third-party systems or external users accessing SAP, address that in the contract. It’s usually cheaper to bundle the needed Digital Access licenses or extra FUEs from the start than to pay penalties or true-up costs later because you overlooked an integration.
- Establish governance and monitoring: Treat the cloud subscription as a living contract that needs oversight. Set up processes to track how many users you have active, how close you are to any usage caps (like integration calls or storage), and whether you’re meeting SLAs. Regularly review this data – it will help you optimize usage, avoid surprises, and have informed conversations with SAP during the contract term.
Checklist: 5 Actions to Take
- Assess current state: Document your existing SAP landscape – what licenses you own, how they’re used, customizations in place, and which third-party systems interface with SAP. This will highlight what must transition to the private cloud and what can be left behind.
- Define future requirements: Collaborate with IT and business leaders to outline the requirements for SAP ERP Private Cloud. Determine the number of users, required modules, performance or availability needs, and integration points. These requirements will shape your contract and the overall project plan.
- Engage with SAP (and experts) early: Initiate open discussions with SAP well ahead of your renewal or project timeline. Solicit a proposal and have it reviewed by your internal experts or an independent advisor. This early review can identify hidden costs, overly restrictive terms, or assumptions that require clarification before you begin negotiations.
- Negotiate the contract: Don’t rush the signing. Negotiate methodically, covering pricing, term length, renewal terms, included services, and exit options. Involve procurement and legal to ensure the contract is enterprise-friendly. Ensure that all promises are documented in writing. If something is important to you (e.g., a flexible renewal or a specific service level), get it in the contract.
- Prepare for migration: Once the contract is in place, create a detailed migration plan. Include data migration steps, setting up your new cloud environments, a period for dual running if needed, and user training on the new system. Also, plan a post-migration license compliance check to verify you’re within the contract terms (correct number of users, proper license assignments) after go-live. Good preparation will smooth out the technical transition and the license management in the new environment.
10 Things IT Sourcing Should Know About SAP ERP Private Cloud
FAQs
Q1: How is SAP ERP Private Cloud different from traditional on-premise SAP?
A: With on-premise SAP, you purchase perpetual software licenses and run the system on your infrastructure (and pay annual maintenance for support). With SAP ERP Private Cloud, you subscribe to a service – SAP provides the software, infrastructure, and support in a bundle. You trade off control for convenience: SAP handles upgrades and hosting, but you must abide by their cloud contract and continue to pay the subscription to use the software. It’s essentially SAP as a Service.
Q2: What happens to our existing SAP licenses if we move to SAP ERP Private Cloud?
A: In many cases, you can trade in your on-premise licenses for credits toward the cloud subscription (SAP often has conversion programs as part of RISE deals). Trading them in means those old perpetual licenses are retired – you can’t use them independently anymore. If you choose not to convert some licenses, you could keep them on the shelf as a fallback, but you generally cannot run them in production once you’re live in the cloud. Always clarify this in your contract so you know whether your old licenses are being terminated or just put on hold during the subscription.
Q3: Can we customize SAP ERP Private Cloud in the same way as our old on-premises system?
A: Yes, if you choose the private cloud edition of S/4HANA, you get a dedicated SAP instance that you can configure and customize extensively. You can carry over most ABAP custom code, do modifications, and use add-ons (subject to SAP’s approval), similar to an on-prem setup. One catch: SAP will still enforce periodic upgrades to your system, so you’ll need to adjust and test your custom code when those updates happen. In contrast, the public cloud edition of SAP S/4HANA (multi-tenant) allows far less customization – but with private cloud, you retain a high degree of flexibility, along with the responsibility to keep your customizations compatible with SAP’s upgrade schedule.
Q4: Can we adjust our user count or subscription if our needs change?
A: You can always increase your subscription (add more users or additional services) by talking to SAP – that part is easy. But reducing your subscription is generally only possible at the end of the term. During your contract term, you’re committed to the number of users and components you signed up for. This is why sizing the deal correctly up front is so important. At renewal time, you can attempt to negotiate a reduction if your needs have decreased; however, mid-term downsizing is not typically permitted in SAP’s cloud contracts.
Q5: Is SAP ERP Private Cloud cheaper in the long run than on-premise?
A: Not always. The private cloud helps avoid big upfront costs and can lower some IT overhead (since SAP runs the infrastructure and basic support). Still, the subscription fees over 5–10 years can end up similar to or even higher than the total costs of an on-premise solution. Essentially, you might be paying a bit more for the convenience and agility that the cloud provides. Many companies find that worthwhile – you get faster innovation and don’t need to maintain hardware – but it’s crucial to run the numbers for your situation. In some cases, if you already have sunk costs in licenses and a well-optimized on-prem setup, the cloud might come out slightly more expensive. The decision usually comes down to strategic factors (innovation, flexibility, risk transfer) rather than just raw cost savings.
Read about our SAP Advisory services for Rise.
