Strategic Management and Negotiation of Oracle Partitioning Licenses
Managing Oracle Partitioning licenses isn’t just about understanding costs and compliance; it requires strategic planning and negotiation. In this article, aimed at CIOs, CTOs, and procurement leaders, we discuss how to strategically manage Oracle Partitioning licensing within an enterprise.
Topics include incorporating Partitioning into long-term IT strategy, negotiating with Oracle for better terms (such as discounts, enterprise agreements, or ULAs), and aligning Partitioning deployment with business needs to maximize value.
The goal is to empower enterprise decision-makers with tactics for maximizing partitioning’s ROI and avoiding overspending or underutilizing this powerful but expensive Oracle Database option.
Aligning Partitioning Licensing with IT Strategy
Oracle Partitioning should be a part of your broader IT and data management strategy, not an afterthought:
- Assess Business Needs: First, evaluate where improved database performance (via Partitioning) is truly needed in your business. For example, if your customer analytics platform struggles with huge tables, that’s a candidate for Partitioning. But if another system has a moderate data size and good performance, you might not need partitioning there. Align Partitioning deployments to where it drives business value (faster reports, better user experience, etc.).
- License Planning in Architecture: When designing new systems or upgrades, factor Partitioning licenses into the architecture decisions. If a new application generates a multi-terabyte database, plan whether partitioning will be used and budget those licenses from the start. Sometimes, the potential cost might influence choosing a different design (for example, sharding data across multiple Standard Edition databases as an alternative approach).
- Enterprise Architecture Standards: Consider making partitioning part of your company’s standard toolkit for large-scale systems. If so, plan a centralized approach to licensing it, such as having a corporate Partitioning license pool that can be allocated to projects as needed. This ensures you don’t have each project separately scrambling for budget when they need the feature.
- Sunset and Consolidation Plans: If you have older systems using Partitioning, include their license footprint in any consolidation or decommission plans. For instance, if two legacy apps each have Partitioning licenses and you plan to merge them into one platform, you may be able to free up some licenses (or avoid buying new ones) by repurposing the existing ones, or possibly reducing the total core count used.
Negotiation Tactics with Oracle for Partitioning
When it comes time to buy Partitioning licenses (or more of them), how you negotiate can significantly affect the price and terms:
- Understand Oracle’s Sales Motivation: Oracle sales representatives often have quarterly and annual targets. Timing your purchase can matter—the end of Oracle’s fiscal quarter or year can make prices more flexible. Also, if your Partitioning requirement can be bundled into a larger purchase (like database licenses or cloud credits), Oracle might discount it more heavily to secure the bigger deal.
- Benchmark Pricing: Go into negotiations knowing what discounts similar enterprises get. Partitioning is a relatively common option; large customers often negotiate anywhere from 10% to 60% off, depending on volume and context. Gather intel on typical discount ranges if you have relationships with peers or use a procurement advisory. Oracle won’t volunteer a big discount unless pressed.
- Use Future Business as Leverage: If you anticipate future Oracle needs (e.g., “We might move to Oracle Cloud” or “We may license other options like RAC or Multitenant”), mention it. Oracle may give a better deal on Partitioning now if they see a longer-term revenue opportunity. Be careful not to over-commit or promise what you can’t deliver, but expressing openness to broader partnership can soften their stance.
- Multi-year Agreements: You can often get more value if you commit to a multi-year deal or a larger Enterprise License Agreement (ELA). For example, negotiating a three-year deal for a set number of Partitioning licenses with fixed support costs can guard against price increases and provide budget predictability. In an ELA context, you can deploy Partitioning on as many servers as needed up to a certain metric cap, which provides flexibility.
- ULA (Unlimited License Agreement) Consideration: If Partitioning is just one of many Oracle products you consume at scale, a ULA might be attractive. ULAs typically include all Oracle Database options. Negotiating a ULA: Ensure that partitioning is listed explicitly if you need it. During negotiation, estimate how many Partitioning deployments you plan under the ULA and use that to argue for a favorable price (Oracle will price ULAs based on their estimate of your usage; your job is to convince them it’s less, while you aim to use more). A well-executed ULA can effectively result in many Partitioning licenses at a fixed cost, drastically lowering the per-unit cost if you deploy widely.
- Concessions and Trade-offs: Perhaps you’re renewing database support or buying cloud services – ask for Partitioning licenses as a throw-in or at least at cost. Oracle sometimes would rather discount options than cut database license or cloud prices because options can have high margins. Use that: push for a “sweetener” where you get a certain number of Partitioning licenses at a steep discount if you sign a larger deal. Also consider negotiating support terms (e.g., a cap on support fee increases, or a higher discount on support for the new licenses).
License Management in Complex Environments
Enterprises often have complex setups, multiple data centers, a hybrid cloud, etc. Managing Partitioning licenses strategically in such environments is crucial:
- Central License Management Team: For large Oracle shops, it pays to have a dedicated license manager or team (IT Asset Management) that oversees all Oracle licensing. They can track partitioning usage across the organization and decide when and where to deploy new licenses rather than reassign existing ones. This central view prevents redundant purchases. For example, if Department A decommissions a database with Partitioning licenses, those licenses can be reallocated to a new project in Department B rather than buying new ones.
- Cloud and Virtualization Strategy: If your enterprise is moving to the cloud or using virtualization like VMware, plan Partitioning licensing accordingly. With cloud, you might use Oracle’s cloud services where licensing is included in the subscription (to avoid managing licenses altogether). Or if using AWS/Azure with BYOL, ensure your cloud architecture (like limiting the number of vCPUs for Oracle) aligns with the Partitioning licenses you own. In VMware or other on-prem virtual environments, use hard partitioning or dedicated hosts for Oracle to avoid a sprawl requiring every host’s licensing. Strategically containing Oracle workloads can save you on Partitioning license costs by reducing the footprint that must be licensed.
- Mergers & Acquisitions: If your company acquires another company or vice versa, Oracle licenses can often be transferred (with Oracle’s approval). This is a strategic opportunity: a newly merged company might end up with excess licenses of some options and deficits of others. Work with Oracle to redistribute or convert licenses if possible. For instance, you might negotiate with Oracle to convert some unused licenses of a different product into Partitioning licenses (Oracle sometimes allows conversions or migrations as part of a deal-making, especially if moving to cloud or newer products).
- Retirement and Shelfware Avoidance: Keep an eye on whether you have Partitioning licenses that are not being used (shelfware). If so, develop a plan: either deploy them for beneficial use (maybe there’s a system suffering performance issues that could use partitioning since you already have the licenses) or trim them. While you can’t typically “sell back” licenses to Oracle, if you truly have surplus, you might negotiate a give-back in exchange for credit towards other Oracle products (this is rare but possible in large enterprise negotiations as part of a bigger deal).
- Third-Party Support and License Lifecycle: Strategically, the main ongoing cost is support once an Oracle Partitioning license is purchased. After several years, some enterprises switch certain databases to third-party support to save costs, especially if those databases are stable and not to be upgraded. If you go this route for Partitioning, include it in your strategy. For example, “We will pay Oracle support on Partitioning for 3 years, then consider third-party support for year 4 onwards if no new features are needed.” Oracle might counter by offering a small discount to keep you on their support, which could also be used as a negotiation chip.
Maximizing ROI from Partitioning Licenses
To justify the cost of Partitioning, ensure you’re getting tangible benefits:
- Measure Performance Gains: After implementing Partitioning on a system, measure the before-and-after metrics (query time, batch processing time, etc.). Quantify these improvements in business terms (e.g., reports run 50% faster, saving analysts 10 hours a week). This data justifies the purchase internally and arms you in negotiations with Oracle (you can say “Partitioning is critical to us, but at the prices we need to ensure we see value – help us make it affordable”).
- Full Utilization: If you have licensed Partitioning on a server with multiple databases, use it across all those databases if beneficial. For instance, if a server with 16 cores is fully licensed for Partitioning, any database on that server can use it without extra cost. Encourage your DBAs to enable it in all applicable schemas on that machine to fully utilize the license. (Of course, only where it improves things – don’t partition just to partition.)
- Review and Prune: Periodically review to see if partitioning is still needed for a given application. Sometimes data volumes might drop, or the app might be phased out. If a system no longer needs Partitioning, you could reassign that license elsewhere (or reduce your renewal if you plan to drop it entirely). Oracle’s licenses are typically perpetual and tied to your company, not a specific server, so you can move them as hardware and systems change.
- Stay Current (Strategically): Oracle continuously improves features. If you’re paying support, you can upgrade to newer Oracle versions, which may have better Partitioning capabilities or performance. Plan version upgrades to maximize the utility of your licenses. At the same time, assess if any Oracle policy changes might affect Partitioning licensing (e.g., if Oracle were ever to bundle Partitioning into some offering or change prices – unlikely in the short term, but always possible long-term).
Negotiation Case Example
Consider a manufacturing enterprise that anticipated needing Partitioning for a new IoT analytics platform (massive data ingestion expected).
They knew it would require 16 processor licenses of Partitioning over 2 years. Instead of buying piecemeal, they engaged Oracle in a negotiation:
- They bundled this Partitioning need with a renewal of their database licenses and an expansion of an Oracle Cloud service.
- They timed it for Oracle’s Q4, incentivizing Oracle to close a big deal.
- They got a 35% discount on the Partitioning licenses and a cap of 3% annual increase on support (instead of the usual 4%).
- Additionally, they negotiated a clause to swap up to 5 of those Partitioning licenses for other database options of equal value if their needs changed within a year (this kind of flexibility can sometimes be negotiated for large deals).
This strategic approach saved them money and gave them flexibility. As their needs evolved (they later decided to implement Advanced Compression, too), they used that swap clause to convert some Partitioning licenses into Compression licenses, avoiding a new purchase.
Recommendations
- Integrate Licensing with Planning: Always include Partitioning licensing discussions in IT project planning. Early awareness prevents scrambling for a budget later and ensures optimal contract terms.
- Keep Oracle Account Team Engaged: Maintain a professional relationship with Oracle representatives. Discuss your roadmap (in general terms) so they understand upcoming needs – this can prompt them to offer programs or discounts proactively.
- Aim for Bundle Deals: Whenever possible, bundle Partitioning licenses with larger negotiations (database purchases, cloud commitments). Oracle is more likely to concede on price or terms for options when tied to strategic deals.
- Explore ULAs Carefully: If you have broad Oracle needs, evaluate an Oracle ULA including Partitioning. It can offer great value if you truly plan heavy usage, but ensure you have an exit strategy for when the ULA ends (e.g., understanding how many licenses you’ll certify). Use expert help to structure it favorably.
- Document License Assignments: Keep a dynamic document or license management system that shows where each Partitioning license is deployed. Review it quarterly to see if you can shuffle licenses around for better use or if you need additional licenses shortly.
- Prepare a Negotiation Plan: Before talking to Oracle, have a clear list of wants: e.g., “We need 10 licenses now, likely 10 more next year—let’s negotiate the price for 20 with an option to true up next year at the same discount.” Oracle can be flexible with the structure if it means locking in your commitment.
- Don’t Overbuy (Avoid Shelfware): It’s easy to be persuaded into buying more licenses “just in case.” Purchase based on realistic plans, with maybe a small buffer. You can always buy more later (especially if you negotiated a price hold for a year or two). Unused licenses just incur support costs with no benefit.
- Review Contracts for Transfer/Merge Clauses: If your business might change (mergers, divestments), ensure your Oracle contracts allow license transfers within affiliates. Strategize Partitioning licensing so that if part of your business is sold, you can allocate some licenses to that entity or recover them, with Oracle’s consent. This flexibility can be negotiated upfront rather than later.
- Stay Agile: Technology needs change. Partitioning may be critical today, but in a few years, a different Oracle feature or a new technology (like big data platforms) will reduce reliance on it. So, avoid getting locked into massive long-term commitments solely for Partitioning. Keep your options open if you need to pivot (for example, negotiating the ability to trade some Partitioning licenses for other software or cloud credits).
Read Oracle Partitioning License Compliance: Avoiding Audit Risks and Penalties.
FAQ
Q1: How much discount can we realistically negotiate on Partitioning licenses?
A1: It varies, but large enterprises often secure significant discounts. Discounts in the 20-50% off list price range are not uncommon if you have leverage (volume or strategic importance to Oracle). Factors include timing (year-end deals often come with bigger discounts), how badly Oracle needs your deal for quota, and whether Partitioning is part of a bigger purchase. Smaller deals might only get 5-15%. Always start negotiations asking for more than you expect (e.g., ask for 50% off if you’d be happy with 30%). Also, negotiate a support discount if possible – Oracle typically doesn’t discount support much. Still, if you get a 30% license discount, the support cost is effectively reduced because it’s calculated on that net license fee.
Q2: Should we include Partitioning licenses in a global Enterprise Agreement or keep them separate?
A2: It can simplify management if you have a global or enterprise agreement (like an ELA or ULA) covering Oracle Database, including Partitioning. It ensures all parts of your company are covered to use Partitioning as needed without separate procurement. It’s usually beneficial if you anticipate broad usage. However, including more products can raise the cost of the agreement, so only include Partitioning if you plan to use it widely enough. In a ULA, include Partitioning if any significant use is expected – the incremental cost in a ULA is often minimal compared to buying it later. An ELA (fixed quantity agreement) can lock a good discount. If your usage is isolated to a few instances, you might just handle those with regular licenses outside the big agreement. Evaluate the trade-off of convenience vs. cost.
Q3: Can we negotiate the 25 Named User Plus (NUP) per processor minimum?
A3: The 25 NUP per processor minimum is a standard Oracle policy, not typically negotiable on paper. Oracle won’t usually waive it in a contract. However, suppose this minimum is causing you to pay for more users than you have. In that case, your best bet is to switch to processor licensing or negotiate a discount that effectively compensates for the extra cost. In some cases, Oracle might allow an exception in specific cases (especially in older contracts, there have been instances of different minimums), but it’s rare now. It’s safer to assume you cannot change the rule, and instead focus on the best financial approach under that rule.
Q4: We plan to move some databases to Oracle’s Autonomous Database service. How does that affect Partitioning licensing?
A4: Oracle’s Autonomous Database (and other Database Cloud Services) include all the database features (Partitioning, RAC, etc.) in the cloud subscription price. If you move to that service, you don’t need to bring your Partitioning licenses for those databases – you are essentially renting the capability as part of the service. Strategically, suppose you have existing on-prem Partitioning licenses and migrate those databases to Autonomous DB. In that case, you might repurpose those licenses elsewhere on-prem (if the contract allows) or possibly decide not to renew support on them (if you don’t need them anymore). But beware: holding onto the licenses (keeping support active) could be wise if you think you might bring some workloads back on-prem. Also, if you have a pool of licenses, Oracle might let you convert unused on-prem licenses to cloud credits under certain programs – something to discuss with them.
Q5: Can we transfer Partitioning licenses between countries or entities within our company?
A5: Oracle licenses are generally global (unless your contract restricts usage to a region), so you can use them in any country your company operates in. Transferring between legal entities (like a subsidiary to a parent) usually requires Oracle’s approval, but it’s typically fine if it’s within the same Ultimate Parent company. Always inform Oracle in writing if there’s a legal entity change to keep records straight. Suppose your company formally splits or divests a division that uses Oracle Partitioning. In that case, those licenses can’t just go with the divested unit unless Oracle agrees (they often will with proper arrangements, possibly for a fee). It’s a strategic consideration in negotiations if you foresee organizational changes.
Q6: We have extra database licenses; can we use those for Partitioning instead?
A6: No, unfortunately not. Oracle Database Enterprise Edition licenses and Partitioning option licenses are separate products. You can’t repurpose a spare Database EE license to cover Partitioning usage. You must have the specific Partitioning option license to legally use that feature. However, in a negotiation scenario, if you have a surplus of one type and need another, Oracle might allow a deal where you drop some excess licenses in exchange for credit toward Partitioning licenses (they have done “license migrations” in some cases). This would likely involve some fees or support adjustments, but if you’re paying support on shelfware licenses, Oracle might prefer to sell you something you’ll use.
Q7: What if Oracle increases the price of Partitioning in the future? How to protect our organization?
A7: Oracle’s list prices don’t change often for core products (they’ve been $11,500 per processor for Partitioning for quite a while). They often adjust support percentages or introduce new offerings at different price points. However, to be safe, get quotes locked in for a period when negotiating. For instance, negotiate that additional Partitioning licenses purchased in the next 12 months will get the same discount or unit price. Also, Oracle’s contracts generally fix the support price to your initial purchase price, so even if the list price goes up, your support increases should still be based on your discounted purchase price. If price protection is a concern, consider it during negotiation (e.g., “We want the ability to buy 10 more licenses next year at the same price per license as this year”). Oracle might not always agree in writing, but it’s a point of discussion.
Q8: Are there any opportunities to get Partitioning for free from Oracle?
A8: Oracle typically does not give Partitioning for free if it’s actively used – it’s a revenue generator for them. That said, on rare occasions, Oracle has included certain options at no cost for specific editions or promotions. For example, Oracle sometimes bundles limited use of certain features with Standard Edition (Partitioning is not one of them now). Another angle: Oracle might loan you licenses for a trial or include Partitioning in a time-bound evaluation if you’re a strategic customer. But for production use, expect to pay. The best “free” scenario is using Oracle’s cloud, which is included in the subscription, but then you’re paying Oracle for the cloud service anyway. Essentially, consider Partitioning a paid feature; your aim should be to get it at the lowest cost, rather than free.
Q9: How does third-party support affect our Partitioning license strategy?
A9: Third-party support (from companies like Rimini Street, for example) can drastically cut annual support fees, but it comes with trade-offs: you won’t get updates from Oracle. If you choose third-party support for your Oracle Database, and options:
- You should only do this if you plan to keep your current database version for a long time or the system is in maintenance mode.
- It can save ~50% of support costs or more. That means your Partitioning licenses still exist; you just pay someone else for support. This could be a strategy after you’ve purchased all needed licenses and find Oracle’s support costs too high for older systems.
- Note that Oracle will consider your licenses “out of support.” If you need to return to Oracle support in the future (to upgrade or get back into compliance with newer versions), they may charge back support fees for the gap period. So, factor in the potential cost if there’s any chance you’ll need Oracle support again.
Strategically, some companies threaten to move to third-party support as a negotiation tactic to get Oracle to reduce support costs or provide discounts on new purchases. Oracle wants to keep you on their support so that they might offer a concession. This can be delicate but part of an advanced negotiation strategy.
Q10: What internal stakeholders should be involved in the Partitioning license strategy?
A10: It’s best to take a cross-functional approach:
- IT Leadership (CIO/CTO): to align technology needs with budget and risk tolerance.
- Procurement/Sourcing: Lead negotiations and ensure the best pricing/terms.
- IT Asset Management / Software Licensing Team: Provide data on current entitlements, usage, and compliance, and manage licenses daily.
- Database Architects/DBAs: to give input on technical needs for Partitioning, potential alternatives, and to ensure any strategy is workable.
- Finance: because these licenses and support carry significant costs, finance should validate ROI and assist in budgeting for large purchases or ULAs.
Combining all these stakeholders ensures that Partitioning licensing decisions make sense technically, financially, and contractually. It prevents siloed decisions like a DBA enabling a feature or a procurement person cutting a deal without full context. A strategic approach is truly a team effort in an enterprise setting.
Read more about our Oracle License Management Service.
